“How am I to know?”
“How am I to know?” is the ironic caption on William Hummer’s yearbook photo from Dover High School, class of 1941.
William “Bill” Minton Hummer was killed in Operation Varsity in WWII at the age of 22. He was a stand-in for a regular crew member on an extremely dangerous mission, dropping supplies at tree-level to troops in heavy fighting in Germany just before the end of the war. According to the 44th Bomb Group historian, due to the risk of friendly-fire accidents, the B-24s on this mission were unarmed and forbidden to shoot, even under fire. B-24 Liberator “Kay Bar” was brought down by small arms fire on the ground, reportedly while one of the young American crewmen was standing in the open door of the plane.
This incident has been painstakingly researched by myself and by my friend and client, the late Peter Loncke of Belgium, who located the crash site near Wesel, Germany.
Much more was discovered, including information learned by Peter about a 15-year-old German boy who was pressed into service by the Nazis and forced to be on the gun crew that shot down Kay Bar and another B-24, the Southern Comfort, which crashed a very short distance away. The young man was so appalled and terrified at having winessed the downing of the two planes that he fled his unit and hid out on a farm for the rest of the war. Peter Loncke had the opportunity to meet this courageous man.
In June 2014, Hummer’s hometown newspaper, the Daily Record, ran a story about the Kay Bar crew and asked the Mine Hill community for help in locating any surviving family members of William Hummer. DeWitt R. Hummer, who served in the Army in WWII and survived the war, has been identified as Williams older brother, which was a starting point in our search. The article resulted in the first photos of William Hummer that the research community had seen, contributed by the Dover Historical Society.
Although many readers wrote in to assist, the search continued for many months for surviving family of William “Bill” Hummer. Wanting to share William’s story with his surviving family members, many people devoted countless hours in the search.
Finally, in September, we made contact with first a daughter and then a son of DeWitt Hummer. The son, named after his father’s beloved brother, is William Minton Hummer II.
While the search continues for the eldest child of DeWitt Hummer, Morris County is set to honor 2nd Lt. William M. Hummer with its Distinguished Military Service Medal on November 12, 2014. Mine Hill Mayor Sam Morris will accept the medal on behalf of the Hummer family.
I’m thrilled that this young man is being honored in this way. I wouldn’t miss it for the world.
Special thanks to the 44th Bomb Group Historian Roger Fenton, and to the Dover Historical Society, Mine Hill Mayor Sam Morris, Jan Williams, Stanley Schoonmaker, Charles Jurgensen, and the tireless and devoted Roger Flartey for your exemplary efforts in honoring one young veteran who sacrificed a life he loved for each of us.
Related articles:
2nd Lt. William M. Hummer
Daily Record
Ask Bill or comment on this story Click here to cancel reply.
Five From the 464th Bomb Group
The 15th Army Air Force, based in...Wee Willie and the photo that started it all
Above is B-17 “Wee Willie”...From Panatella to Ploesti
The 15th Army Air Force, based in...Six B-24s From Baker Box Downed
The men – the boys, really...Debut for Debach
It was the very first combat mission...The World War II Dead of University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA)
More than 260 UCLA students, faculty ...
SSGT Morris Meyers: The Man My Dad Never Stopped Waiting For
SSGT Morris Meyers | The Man My Dad...TEC5 Genaro A. Caruso — What the Records Don’t Tell Us
(Troop C, 25th Cavalry Reconnaissance...Nicasio C. Sifuentes: One Week at the Front
(Company A, 10th Armored Infantry...PFC Oscar B. Oakman: The Last Man to Die in the 94th Armored Field Artillery Battalion
(PFC Oscar B. Oakman, 4th Armored...The 4th Armored Division: The Spearhead of Patton’s Third Army
Activated in April 1941 at Pine Camp,...Talk Radio One’s Steven Spierer Interviews WW2 Researcher Bill Beigel
Steven Spierer Talk Radio One Interview...
LOST B-25 “El Aguila” (“The Eagle”) With Crew and Passengers
Hi Georgia: So sorry for this slow response. I'd love to connect with you some time. I suspect that there is information on your great-uncle that is unknown to you. Rather than write up a lengthy e-mail, I suggest that we get on the phone for a brief discussion of our research options. Please use this link: https://calendly.com/ww2research/30min to my calendar to schedule a phone meeting. There is no cost for this research consultation with me; I look forward to talking with you. Best regards, BillSix B-24s From Baker Box Downed
Hello April: Sorry for this slow response. I'd be happy to trade some history with you. You can reach me at bill.beigel@ww2research.com. I might even be able to locate some information that is new to you. Best, BillFive From the 464th Bomb Group
Hi Janice: I apologize for my late replay to your note! We can certainly re-create your father's service with the 454th Bomb Group. Rather than write up a lengthy e-mail, I suggest that we get on the phone for a brief discussion of our research options. Please use this link: https://calendly.com/ww2research/30min to my calendar to schedule a phone meeting. There is no cost for this research consultation with me; I look forward to talking with you. Best regards, BillThe Murder of WAC Private Byrl Babcock
I agree with Vanessa. This is such a compelling story and so well written. It really packed a punch to read that she didn’t return to her base after her leave ended… there was no answer at the hotel room… she and her husband both died of gunshot wounds…Lt. Ecke personally accompanied Byrl’s casket on the journey to CA, stood as honor guard during the funeral, and presented the flag to Byrl’s mother. I loved learning that her headstone did NOT have the last name of her abusive husband who murdered her! I am very curious now to look at WW2 memorials to see if I can find any women’s names listed. It never occurred to me to look before.SSGT Morris Meyers: The Man My Dad Never Stopped Waiting For
So you know how I feel about my cousin, 2Lt A.D. (Alvis Deryl) Noble, I know that he was born on my grandfather's farm in Hopkins Co. Texas, where my father and his and 5 other brothers and 4 sisters were born, then the next information I have is the casualty report after his death as his records were lost in the St. Louis fire. I was born in 1956, 12 years after his death. But I want to thank you once again for your help with what I do know about 2Lt Noble. Sincerely A .D. ( Alan Dale ) NobleSSGT Morris Meyers: The Man My Dad Never Stopped Waiting For
WOW. Great job Something like that for the crew of the B2 nine Salvo Sally that bombed Masaki yes Japan on April 28, 1945. The flight engineer Fred MacDonald was my first cousin husband. The plane went in the ocean. Most likely the gunners are got out and got in parachutes, but only one survived and I found him in St. Louis Missouri Japan held a huge memorial for the crew on April 28, 2018. The survivor was Jack B Cannon. He died. I think he was 94.

































BILL
I enjoyed reading your articles very much. I’m sure the families were very grateful for the information you provided.
Hi Marie:
Thanks for taking the time to look at my website!
Best regards, Bill
I’m the ex wife of William Hummer II, I cannot express my gratitude enough for taking this on. It is history for our girls, Krystyn and Melissa Hummer
Hi Leslie:
I’m delighted that my research has been of value to you and your family!
Best regards, Bill